Ahenakew hate crime conviction overturned

[Guest]

UPDATED
January 14, 2008

Saskatchewan Court of Appeal affirms a new trial for David Ahenakew for wilfully promoting hatred . . .
http://www.turtleisland.org/discussion/ ... =8893#8893

- - -

David Ahenakew's hate crime conviction for remarks about the Jews has been set aside by Saskatchewan court . . . New trial ordered!
June 2006
http://204.83.249.88/judgments/2006/QB2 ... kqb272.pdf
NOTE this is a link to a .pdf file

Jun 09, 2006 - CJC comments on decision in Ahenakew appeal
For immediate release

TORONTO – Canadian Jewish Congress National President Ed Morgan made the following statement on the appeal which set aside David Ahenakew’s conviction for willfully promoting hatred against Jewish people and ordered a new trial:

“The purpose of CJC’s intervention in this appeal was to protect the validity and relevance of Canada’s anti-hate laws.

“Two issues were at stake in this appeal: the first was the interpretation of one of the law’s elements, specifically what constitutes a private conversation. The second was Ahenakew’s guilt or innocence based on the willfulness of his intent to promote hatred.

“We’re pleased that Chief Justice Laing upheld CJC’s argument that Ahenakew’s remarks to the reporter did not constitute a private conversation as the defence alleged, but were in fact a public conversation and therefore potentially subject to criminal sanction.

“The appeal judge also ordered a new trial because he felt the case warranted a more thorough consideration of the nature of Ahenakew’s intent in uttering his now-notorious statements about the Jews and Hitler.

“We respect the judicial process and have every confidence in the Crown to make appropriate choice as to whether or not it will appeal today’s decision, or proceed directly to a new trial.”

-30-
Contact:
Wendy Lampert
National Communications Director
Canadian Jewish Congress
416-631-5844 (office)
wlampert@on.cjc.ca
www.cjc.ca

- - - - - - -

Largest ever mission to Israel by First Nations leaders
February 17, 2006
http://www.turtleisland.org/discussion/ ... =6646#6646

- - - - - - -

Building bridges between Aboriginal Canadians and the Jewish community, here and abroad . . .

August 5th, 2005
http://www.turtleisland.org/discussion/ ... =5928#5928

- - - - - - -

David Ahenakew was found guilty of a hate crime, for his anti-Jewish (racist) remarks . . .

(Saskatchewan Provincial Court Judgment - NOTE: It is a .pdf file
http://www.lawsociety.sk.ca/judgments/2 ... skpc76.pdf )

News and Comment
by Tehaliwaskenhas
Bob Kennedy, Oneida
Copyright
Turtle Island Native Network
http://www.turtleisland.org

July 9, 2005

It is true Aboriginal people continue to be subjected to racist attitudes. It is true Aboriginal people have been treated unfairly by a 'foreign' justice system of Canada.

However, I think the appropos phrase is, Two Wrongs Do Not Make a Right.

A former top First Nation leader, David Ahenakew was found guilty of a hate crime, in connection with his anti-Jewish remarks.

Saskatchewan provincial court Judge Marty Irwin fined Ahenakew $1,000 for wilfully promoting hatred. The judge said he imposed "an appropriate fine" to prevent Ahenakew from becoming a "martyr" for racists and bigots.

But Ahenakew still proclaimed his innocence and said he plans to appeal the conviction. Earlier this week, it was revealed federal officials are preparing documents to make sure Ahenakew loses his Order of Canada. But Ahenakew said he plans to fight that too.

Who sparked all of this? David Ahenakew!

What sparked all of this, was when he told a Saskatoon reporter that the Holocaust was a good thing and praised Adolf Hitler for having "fried" six million Jews during World War II.

After the s _ _ t hit the fan, Ahenakew, who is 71 years of age, apologized. Also, at one point he blamed his diabetes for his racist tangent.

But now he blames the justice system for being racist against First Nations people.

I cannot get inside his head to fully understand his reaction, but I get the sense that if he had been left alone after his initial apology, Mr. Ahenakew would have been satisifed. Unfortunately, the 'system' was not. There was a hue and cry by Jewish rights organizations, politicians of all stripes, including some highly placed Aboriginal leaders.

The Mounties were instructed by Saskatchewan Justice to launch a criminal investigation. They concluded a crime was committed and they were compelled to lay a charge of "promoting hatred".

If his December 2002 comments that caused this storm of controversy, were the result of decades of frustration, boiling over from within David Ahenakew, who has fought for Aboriginal rights in an arena of the "haves and have-nots", his words were far from measured, respectful, appropriate or beneficial.

Rather than accepting responsibility for his words, after being convicted and sentenced, he called the charge against him of inciting hatred, ridiculous.

It seems to me, Mr. Ahenakew is his own worst enemy, so to speak. At least one Jewish rights spokesman initially suggested that an Aboriginal approach be considered as an appropriate way to address the issue - perhaps a community circle. But because of Mr. Ahenakew's apparent unwillingness to embrace any reconciliation, the idea was not pursued.

(Imagine how the outcome might have been different, had a healing circle and sentencing circle been agreed to at the outset. Instead, a stubborn and pride-ridden man, must continue to learn his lessons.)

His plea of innocence, is ridiculous. After all, he did admit to making the disparaging remarks about Jews.

How can we expect credibility, when someone like David Ahenakew, who has been a leader of his own oppressed people, delivers powerful words that attack, sting and hurt other people who also have known oppression.

I have found it difficult to point an accusing finger at such a well known First Nation leader, who in the past vehemently spoke out for our interests.

However, when I heard he hired lawyer Douglas Christie to represent him, a very bright red flag went up for me. I know about Mr. Christie from my days as a broadcast journalist in Toronto when he championed the rights of Ernst Zundel, infamous anti-semite, racist and a folk hero for White Supremacists. Mr. Christie argued on the basis of freedom of speech. Zundel has since been kicked out of Canada. To whomever advised Mr. Ahenakew to lean so far to the right to hire Christie, I must advise - get out of the advisory business.

Aside from that, it is very clear and true, that what David Ahenakew said about Jewish people was unfair and unjust. A sincere public apology is necessary, and not an appeal, in a court of a justice system he has condemned.

Shortly after the very dark clouds of outrage formed in December 2002, Turtle Island Native Network received comments from Aboriginal people who felt they needed to deliver key messages to the former AFN leader.

I believe this example speaks volumes, about how some of us felt then, and feel now, " Mr. Ahenakew, why? What could have posessed you to have made such a statement? How long has such bitterness infected your basic moral values? Have you forgotten who you are and where you came from?

I do not wish, nor is my intention to judge you, but you have made it very difficult for me as an aboriginal person not to address this serious matter.

My uncle along with many other aboriginal soldiers gave his life during the war to give all Canadian people and all the people around the world the freedom of which they enjoy today.

Some of our veterans that are still with us today, carry the scars of their sacrifice. Can you look these men in the eye and tell them that their sacrifice was all in vain?

These are some of the things you must think about before you make comments that are both hurtful and hateful.

My Creator does not allow me to be angry towards you, I must show compassion - that is why as I burn my sage - I'm offering the creator this tobacco, that you receive this healing and that he take you on a journey, so that your heart remembers, our relations who gave their lives for us the people of all nations. Miigwetch!"

- - - - - - -

"B’nai Brith Canada said, “Ahenakew has proved yet again that his hate crime conviction is fully justified." Canadian Jewish News . . .
http://www.cjnews.com/viewarticle.asp?id=6873

- - - - - - -
BACKGROUND

June 12, 2003

The Mounties have laid criminal charges against former AFN National Chief David Ahenakew, for hatred remarks he made about Jews, last December.

The Saskatchewan Justice Minister ordered an investigation after both Jewish and Aboriginal leaders expressed outrage over Ahenakew's anti-semitic comments about Jews and favourable words about Hitler's action against them.

The RCMP said the results of their investigation led them to lay charges against Ahenakew under the Criminal Code of Canada.

Saskatchewan's Justice Ministry news release said, "Public Prosecutions, Saskatchewan Justice today announced that David Ahenakew has been charged with promoting hatred under section 319 (2) of the Criminal Code.

The charges arise out of remarks made by Ahenakew in an address to a conference in December 2002."

B'nai Brith Canada welcomed the decision to lay charges against David Ahenakew. Rochelle Wilner, National President, commented, "We applaud the decision of the Saskatchewan Justice Department to proceed with charges against David Ahenakew, as we had requested. At the same time, we will continue our efforts to promote understanding between the Jewish and aboriginal communities."


"This decision demonstrates that the justice system can act if necessary
to protect minority Canadians against the promotion of hatred when there is the will to act," added Frank Dimant, Executive Vice-President.

David Matas, B'nai Brith Senior Legal Counsel added: "We explored the use of the aboriginal justice system as an alternative to the laying of charges, but we understood that the initiative had to come from Ahenakew himself. We are disappointed that he did not show that initiative, but would still support using that system for sentencing if he is convicted and if he initiates the process."

----------------

March 22, 2003

Aboriginal and Jewish community groups continue to meet in Saskatchewan to bridge the gap created by anti-Jewish comments last December.

--------------


Ahenakew's Stupid, Racist Comments Are Still Newsworthy

February 10, 2003

Former Prime Minister Brian Mulroney's anti-semitism speech targeted David Ahenakew's ". . .absolutely pathetic but startling ravings."

In a speech at the University of Toronto to kick off a two-day conference on anti-Semitism, Mulroney specifically noted the notorious comments of former chief of the Assembly of First Nations David Ahenakew and said they highlight the need for vigilance against hatred.

Mulroney said he believes anti-Semitism is born in ignorance and nurtured in envy.

"The rise in the number of attacks on Jews and Jewish institutions in Canada and the absolutely pathetic but startling ravings of David Ahenakew testify to the intractability of the problem and the constant need for vigilance, consistency and strength in dealing with the entire sweep of anti-Semitism."

Last December Ahenakew, a Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations FSIN senator, and an Order of Canada member, told a reporter that Hitler was attempting to -clean up the world- when he -fried- six million Jews in the Holocaust.

Ahenakew offered his resignation and publicly apologized but the FSIN executive removed him, although FSIN senators recently said he could stay. Jewis leaders were again outraged when they heard about that, but FSIN chief Perry Bellegarde said the senators are advisors only and do not have the last say about Ahenakew's future with the FSIN.

----------------------------------------

January 7, 2003

RCMP hate crime investigation into David Ahenakew's pro-Hitler comments is moving forward.

The Mounties showed up with a search warrant Monday at the offices of the Saskatoon Star Phoenix newspaper. The police seized a notebook and audio tape from reporter James Parker who wrote an article in December that described Ahenakew's anti-Jewish comments in a speech and interview that sparked a storm of outrage and prompted Aboriginal leaders to condemn his words.

Ahenakew told the reporter that Adolf Hitler came to power in response to the disease of Jewish domination and was attempting to clean up the world when he fried six million Jews during the Holocaust.

The Mounties launched an investigation at the request of the Saskatchewan Government. Ahenakew could be charged with public incitement of hatred under the Criminal Code.

The question yet to be answered by investigators is did he ". . . willfully promote hatred against an identifiable group?"

----------------------------------------

Ahenakew Apologizes and Resigns!
Anti-Jewish Remarks Spark RCMP Hate Crime Probe in Saskatchewan

Copyright
Turtle Island Native Network
http://www.turtleisland.org

December 17, 2002

David Ahenakew has apologized and resigned!

The First Nation leader apologized for his recent anti-Jewish comments and resigned as a senator of the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations.

The FSIN executive members were going to meet to decide Ahenakew's fate, but he resigned so they wouldn't be put in the position of having to decide what to do about his outrageous and hateful comments about Jews.

The reaction to anti-Jewish remarks by David Ahenakew continues to grow. Stunned and outraged, Canadians from all walks of life are shaking their heads in amazement. The following is an example of the reaction.

It is an e-mail sent to Turtle Island Native Network's DISCUSSSION / FORUMS.

Mr. Ahenakew, why? what could have posessed you to have made such a statement?

How long has such bitterness infected your basic moral values? Have you forgotten who you are and where you came from?

I do not wish nor is my intention to judge you but you have made it very difficult for me as an aboriginal person not to address this serious matter.

My uncle Gerard Mongeon along with many other aboriginal soldiers gave his life during the war to give all canadian people and all the people around the world the freedom of which they enjoy today.

Some of our veterans that are still with us today still carry the scares of their sacrifice. Can you look these men in the eye and tell them that their sacrifice was all in vain? These are some of the things you must think about before you make comments that are both hurtfull and hatefull.

My Creator does not allow me to be angry towards you, I must show compassion that is why as I burn my sage I'm offering the creator this tobacco, that you recieve this healing and that he take you on a journey so that your heart remembers our relations who gave their lives for us the people of all nations.
Miigwetch mmandevi@uoguelph.ca

Metis National Council President Gerald Morin added his voice to the growing chorus of Aboriginal leaders who condemned what Ahenakew said about Jews, - -Our people know all to well the pain caused by hurtful words. Our people know how ignorance about our true history is the basis for many of the racist attitudes that exist today. That is why we must condemn these words.- -

The Attorney General of Saskatchewan has asked the Mounties to investigate a possible hate crime because of the alleged anti-Jewish remarks attributed to David Ahenakew, a senator with the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations and a former National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, and a recipient of the Order of Canada.

Ahenakew seemed to clearly suggest the Nazis were justified in trying to get rid of the Jews. In fact, he referred to them as a disease.

His comments have been attacked as outrageous, shocking, and appalling by Jewish as well as both Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal leaders across Canada.

The Prime Minister has spoken out against Ahenakew's remarks.

So have National Chief Matthew Coon Come, the First Nations Summit in British Columbia, Grand Chief Ted Moses of the Cree, Premier Lorne Calvert of Saskatchewan, and Buzz Hargrove, head of the Canadian Auto workers Union.

"Aboriginal Peoples must speak out and denounce the statements made by David Ahenakew," stated Grand Chief Moses.

The First Nations Summit issued a news release "We wish to make it clear that Mr. Ahenakew does not represent the interests of First Nations in British Columbia and the First Nations Summit does not in any way condone his offensive statements against the Jewish community. Further, these statements do not reflect the views of First Nations in British Columbia."

Matthew Coon Come said "As National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, and on behalf of all First Nations and First Nations peoples from all regions in Canada, I unconditionally reject these hateful, ignorant and unacceptable remarks made by Dr. Ahenakew. These comments are damaging and they are morally offensive. We regret these insulting comments directed at our Jewish brothers and sisters who have in fact supported First Nations in many of our struggles."

In a letter to Prime Minister Chretien, the CAW's Hargrove wrote "We support the RCMP's investigation into the comments of Mr. Ahenakew and would urge that Canada's laws against hate crimes be vigorously enforced. I have written to Governor-General Adrienne Clarkson asking that she refer this matter to the Advisory Council of the Order of Canada for an immediate investigation into the statements attributed to Mr. Ahenakew and if the news reports are correct, we urge the government and the Advisory Council of the Order of Canada to withdraw Mr. Ahenakew's prestigious Order of Canada."


Background on David Ahenakew
http://www.sicc.sk.ca/faces/mahenda.htm

-----------------------

December 17, 2002

Gerald Morin, President of the Métis National Council says, “The MNC joins with all right- minded people across Canada, including other Aboriginal people who have condemned the statements made by David Ahenakew, the former leader of the Assembly of First Nations”.

President Morin, called the anti-Semitic statements quoted in the Saskatoon Star Phoenix as, “hateful and completely unacceptable.” He then added, “As the national representative of the Métis people of the traditional Métis homeland, I offer my sincere regrets to the Jewish people who have been hurt by those words.”

“Our people know all to well the pain caused by hurtful words. Our people know how ignorance about our true history is the basis for many of the racist attitudes that exist today. That is why we must condemn these words.”
President Morin added, “It has always been the belief of the Métis people that Aboriginal rights are human rights. One cannot defend Aboriginal rights at the expense of Human rights and vice versa.”

Although Mr. Ahenakew was never a leader or representative for the Métis people of Canada, there is much concern that the furor unleashed by his ranting is tarnishing all Aboriginal People. “Let’s not allow racism to lead to more racism,” says President Morin. “The words of one individual should not be used to judge all Aboriginal people.”


-30-

For further information please contact:

Miles Morrisseau, Director of Communications
Métis National Council
Work: (613) 232-3216 ext. 110
Cell: (613) 612-5753

Katelin Gillis, Public Relations Officer
Work: (613) 232-3216 ext. 117
Cell: (613) 859-7130
www.metinsnation.ca

-----------------------

December 17, 2002

[Amherst, NS]

The Atlantic Chiefs are outraged that any Aboriginal person would put down any other race the way that former Chief Dave Ahanakew did
this week.

“It’s unforgivable for an Aboriginal Leader to make such statements and it’
s our position that he face the consequences of his outburst,” said APC
Co-Chair Chief Lawrence Paul.

The Atlantic Chiefs want to state that they don’t share the views of Dave
Ahanakew when he said that Adolf Hitler was ‘stopping the Jewish people from taking over Germany and Europe.’

“Mr. Ahanakew does not express the views of the Atlantic Chiefs and should face not only his own people, but also the Jewish people of Canada to apologize for his comments,” said APC Co-Chair Chief Second Peter Barlow.

“Canada fought World War II to help stop Hitler from taking over Europe and to stop him from continuing the genocide of the Jewish people in Germany.

For Mr. Ahanakew to state what he did is not only discriminatory, it’s
outright ludicrous,” continued Chief Barlow.

The Atlantic Chiefs support any action that the Federation of Saskatchewan
Indian Nations deems necessary to rectify this situation and applaud
Assembly of First Nations Vice-Chief Perry Bellegard’s quick response.

“Mr. Ahanakew will have to live with his actions and it may be hard for the
Aboriginal people of Canada to forget that one of their own respected elders would show such disrespect for another culture,” concluded Chief Paul.

-30-

Contact: JJ Bear – Communications Officer – jj.bear@apcfnc.ca

(902) 667-4007 work
(902) 669-0045 Cell

-----------------------

December 16 2002

“I am deeply disturbed to have learned of the extraordinary anti-Semitic and racist remarks attributed to Saskatchewan First Nations Senator Dr. David Ahenakew in newspaper reports.

As National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, and on behalf of all First Nations and First Nations peoples from all regions in Canada, I unconditionally reject these hateful, ignorant and unacceptable remarks made by Dr. Ahenakew.

These comments are damaging and they are morally offensive. We regret these insulting comments directed at our Jewish brothers and sisters who have in fact supported First Nations in many of our struggles”.

Millions of people around the world, including hundreds of thousands of Canadians, responded to the call to defeat Nazi oppression and the march of fascism. Many, including a disproportionate number of First Nations people from Canada, gave their lives in this struggle against Hitler’s evil in Europe and elsewhere.

For hundreds of years, indigenous peoples in Canada and elsewhere in the world have been and are still being subjected to horrendous intolerance, discrimination, racism and various forms of genocide. We have cried out against these continuing injustices, and have been joined by decent and well-meaning people of many races and faiths – including very many Jews – in doing so.

I have contacted Senior representatives in the Jewish community to convey our regrets and offer our assistance in any way that may be helpful to deal with this regrettable situation. We want to ensure the positive relationship we enjoy with the Jewish community remains strong and intact.

“There can never be any justification for racism or genocide, anywhere. Accordingly, First Nations leaders and peoples in Canada reject and dissociate themselves from any action or expression of racism, bigotry, and injustice, no matter whether they are aimed at us or at Jewish, Christian, Muslim, Hindu or any other people.”

The AFN and First Nations find these comments offensive and totally unacceptable. An apology is a necessary first step and further efforts may be required to repair the damage and hurt inflicted by these comments.”

------------

The First Nations Summit is deeply disturbed by the racist and anti-Semitic remarks attributed to Mr. David Ahenakew in today's media reports. We wish to make it clear that Mr. Ahenakew does not represent the interests of First Nations in British Columbia and the First Nations Summit does not in any way condone his offensive statements against the Jewish community. Further, these statements do not reflect the views of First Nations in British Columbia.

The First Nations Summit is proud to have worked hand in hand with many
ethnic groups in the past, including organizations and representatives of the
Jewish community, to fight against the racist attitudes Mr. Ahenakew
represents with his offensive statements.

The First Nations Summit does not tolerate racism directed at Canada's
indigenous people and as such will not tolerate it when it stems from within
one of Canada's indigenous communities. We sincerely hope that mechanisms are
enacted to ensure Mr. Ahenakew is held accountable for his statements. We also urge Mr. Ahenakew to issue an immediate statement of apology to those he has inflicted pain upon with his statements.

The First Nations Summit speaks on behalf of First Nations involved in
the treaty negotiation process in British Columbia. Background information on
the Summit may be found at www.fns.bc.ca.

-30-
For further information: Colin Braker, First Nations Summit, Office:
604-990-9939, Cell: 604-328-4094

---------------

"Aboriginal Peoples must speak out and denounce the statements made by David Ahenakew(1)", stated Grand Chief Moses. "I have spent most of my life fighting for the rights of Indigenous Peoples around the world. Racism has been one of the most powerful forces undermining indigenous rights and we cannot condone statements made by anyone, especially members of the Indigenous Community, that are based on racism directed against any minority.

The Jewish People of Europe were victimized in the Holocaust and before that by the pogroms in Europe. It has been among the worlds most persistently persecuted populations. Many Jewish people have been involved in struggles to defend human rights and have fought hand in hand with indigenous communities in defence of our human rights. We are extremely grateful for this assistance.

For hundreds of years we have had to deal with the consequences of racism directed against our Peoples, racism has long been discredited and cannot form the basis of any legitimate social criticism.

We, as an Indigenous People and as Crees cannot accept this and do not accept it within our own community. The legacy of our Cree ancestors is to respect all people as human beings and equals.

By speaking out against racism we show our commitment to basic principles of human rights and confirm our commitment to our traditions," he concluded.

(1) Mr. Ahenakew's statements were reported by Southam News on
December 16, 2002.

-30-
For further information: Grand Chief Dr. Ted Moses: (514) 861 5837; Bill
Namagoose: Executive Director, (613) 725-7024

----------------

CAW President Buzz Hargrove today sent the following letter to Prime Minister Jean Chrétien expressing shock and dismay about the recent comments attributed to David Ahenakew:

The Right Honourable Jean Chrétien
Prime Minister
House of Commons
Ottawa, ON

Dear Prime Minister,


It was with shock and dismay that I read the recent comments attributed to David Ahenakew, a senator in the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations (FSIN). The Canadian Auto Workers union joins with the Canadian Jewish Congress and the Assembly of First Nations in strongly condemning these statements.

Our Union of 260,000 members places great emphasis on human rights for all world citizens and denounces, in the strongest possible terms, this unwarranted attack on the Jewish people.

We support the RCMP's investigation into the comments of Mr. Ahenakew and would urge that Canada's laws against hate crimes be vigorously enforced.

I have written to Governor-General Adrienne Clarkson asking that she refer this matter to the Advisory Council of the Order of Canada for an immediate investigation into the statements attributed to Mr. Ahenakew and if the news reports are correct, we urge the government and the Advisory Council of the Order of Canada to withdraw Mr. Ahenakew's prestigious Order of Canada.

Your cooperation is appreciated.

Yours truly,

Basil 'Buzz' Hargrove
President

-30-
For further information: CAW Communications: John McClyment - (416) 495-3766

[admin]

Dec 15, 2002 - CJC shocked by Ahenakew’s racist comments

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OTTAWA – Canadian Jewish Congress is appalled by the racist comments of David Ahenakew, senator and former leader of the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations (FISN) and the Assembly of First Nations (AFN). Hateful attacks primarily against the Jewish people as well as members of the South Asian community and others were made during a speech to an FISN conference. The shocking extent of his antisemitism was further revealed in a follow-up interview.

“These vicious and vile remarks stagger the mind and sicken the heart,” states Keith Landy, CJC national president. “Mr. Ahenakew has disgraced himself, his community and the Canadian Armed Forces in which he served. From here on in he ought to be relegated to the obscurity he so richly deserves.”

“We acknowledge that chief Bellegarde dissociated the FISN from the remarks and are encouraged by his declared intention to meet with Saskatchewan's Jewish community,” continues Mr. Landy. “We hope that what would emerge out of such a meeting is the validation of a zero tolerance policy towards any racist expression and a rejection of those who engage in it.”

Mr. Landy says he will contact Assembly of First Nations national chief Matthew Coon Come. “CJC and the AFN have been linked by a shared commitment to pursue justice and combat discrimination. I hope to speak with National Chief Coon Come soon so we can not only reaffirm, but indeed strengthen the very good relationship enjoyed by our two communities,” concludes the CJC leader.

-30-


Contact:
Ron Singer
Director of Communications
613 233-8703 ext 223


MORE ABOUT THIS STORY
http://www.cjc.ca/template.php?action=itn&Story=52

[mmandevi@uoguelph.ca]

Mr. Ahenakew, why? what could have posessed you to have made such a statement? How long has such bitterness infected your basic moral values? Have you forgotten who you are and where you came from? I do not wish nor is my intention to judge you but you have made it very difficult for me as an aboriginal person not to address this serious matter. My uncle Gerard Mongeon along with many other aboriginal soldiers gave his life during the war to give all canadian people and all the people around the world the freedom of which they enjoy today. Some of our veterans that are still with us today still carry the scares of their sacrifice. Can you look these men in the eye and tell them that their sacrifice was all in vain? These are some of the things you must think about before you make comments that are both hurtfull and hatefull. My Creator does not allow me to be angry towards you, I must show compassion that is why as I burn my sage I'm offering the creator this tobacco, that you recieve this healing and that he take you on a journey so that your heart remembers our relations who gave their lives for us the people of all nations. Miigwetch

[mmandevi@uoguelph.ca]

Mr. Ahenakew apologized, he has done an honorable thing. Many people are not satisfied, they want more, they want him put in jail for hate crimes, Well coming from non-native society whats new? I wrote yesterday in responce to Mr. Ahenakew's comments, he made a terrible mistake I watched him on the news and to me he gave a heart felt apology for his mistake, a mistake that cost him his livelyhood and his integredy, a mistake that he will live with probably for the rest of his life, But people around the country just scoffed at his apology, politicians and many other leaders want to see him put in jail, they want his order of canada award taken away. It just shows aboriginal people that thirty years of dedication and service really did'nt mean anything to them anyways it was just a token from them so they could feel good about themselves. Am I doing an about face from yesterdays comments, "Not at all" I still don't agree with Mr. Ahenakew's comments but he has done what he had to do, he apologized, he resigned his posts, he his going through his healing process and now it is time for all native people to stand beside him and help him in this healing. Now watch closely as the Canadian government and many of the non-native population show their true colours and kick this old indian man while he his down, now you will witness real hate crimes, they will make an example of Mr. Ahenakew and make him pay as if he where Hitler himself, because he made a mistake! no not at all, because his an indian maybe?
Mr. Ahenakew this message is for you. You had made a terrible mistake by making such comments that there is no doubt and you paid the price in resigning your posts, You did the honorable thing and apologized to the Jewish people but also know this you have also opened the eyes and ears of canada's native people as they watch what happens next.
And Sir even though yesterday I scolded you, I did not leave you, my prayers where not meant to hurt or harm you in any way, but I am happy that they where answered and the creator touched your heart, and further more weither they take your pin away or not know this that your hard work and dedication on behalf of aboriginal peoples will not be forgotten and I ask all First Nations, Inuit and Metis Peoples by writting and telling you this. Miigwetch

[Guest]

December 17, 2002

Assembly of First Nations National Chief Matthew Coon Come responded today to the apology by Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations Senator David Ahenakew. Ahenakew apologized for racist statements made over the weekend and resigned from all posts he currently holds with the FSIN.

Ahenakew is not affiliated with the Assembly of First Nations, but AFN National Chief Coon Come stated the apology and resignation are important steps in dealing with this deeply troubling situation. Yesterday, the National Chief had condemned the statements by Ahenakew and called for an apology as “a necessary first step, but only a first step.”

“For our peoples, healing traditionally begins by acknowledging the harm and the hurt you’ve inflicted, apologizing to the people you have offended and taking responsibility for your actions,” said the National Chief. “Now, the real work begins - trying to re-build the relationships that have been damaged, working with the parties to make some kind of restitution for the damage inflicted, and working towards reconciliation if at all possible. This will be much more difficult, but the efforts have to be made.”

Investigations continue to determine if Ahenakew will be charged under the Criminal Code, and there are also moves to strip him of his Order of Canada. The National Chief noted that the proper authorities and mechanisms are in place to deal with these legal and procedural matters.

AFN Vice Chief for Saskatchewan, Perry Bellegarde, noted that he had already introduced a strongly worded motion to remove Ahenakew from all posts at the FSIN had he not resigned this morning.

“We hold strongly to our belief and adoption of zero tolerance for racist attitudes and comments directed at our people and we cannot exempt ourselves or any of our own, regardless of their status or standing among our people, from this same code of conduct,” said Vice Chief Bellegarde.

In his statement today, Ahenakew apologized to the Jewish community and other ethnic communities offended by his remarks and apologized for the shame he brought to all First Nations citizens.

“No individual or organization can accept an apology on behalf of someone else,” said National Chief Coon Come. “I accept the apology he made to me as a First Nations person but I speak only for myself. Members of the Jewish community and other cultural groups in Canada will have to decide if today’s statement is an acceptable start. Whatever their decision, I hope we as First Nations can work with any and all other Canadians to move forward from this setback. I will be in contact with my colleagues in the cultural communities to talk about how we can work to restore and strengthen our relationships and keep the circle strong.”

The Assembly of First Nations is the national organization representing First Nations citizens in Canada.



Contact:

Don Kelly, AFN A/Director of Communications
613-241-6789 ext. 320 or cell: 613-292-2787

[Guest]

Keith LandyPresidentCanadian Jewish CongressNational Office
100 Sparks Street, Suite 650Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5B7December 20, 2002
SENT VIA FAX: (613) 233-8748RE: Comments and Apology of David Ahenakew
Dear Mr. Landy:
On behalf of the Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs, I would like
to fully and completely ensure you that this organization does not share
in the totally unacceptable and highly offensive anti-semitic sentiments
expressed last week by David Ahenakew.
I carefully listened to Ahenakew’s apology and I believe that his
resignation from his high-profile political positions represents an
initial step toward a just response to such contemptible comments. As
Ahenakew attests, his actions will speak more than the words of his
apology. I sincerely hope that Ahenakew will extend his hand to the
Jewish community to begin the process of reconciliation.
I would also like to take this opportunity to acknowledge the valuable
support of Nisson Goldman, Chair of the Pacific Region of the Canadian
Jewish Congress who earlier this year spoke out against the results of
the “Referendum on Treaty Principles.” It is such proven support from
the Canadian Jewish Congress that ensures that our respective
communities and organizations may look toward a future of building
strong relationships.
Today, we enjoyed the distinct honour of hosting Mr. Mark Weintraub at
our annual UBCIC Christmas Open House celebration. My wife, Mrs. Joan
Phillip presented Mr. Weintraub with a pair of traditionally beaded
earrings featuring the Star of David.
I will contact Nisson Goldman, Chair of the Pacific Region of the
Canadian Jewish Congress, to meet with myself so that we can discuss
approaches where our organizations can work closely together on areas of
mutual concern.Yours truly,Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs
[Original Signed by Chief Stewart Phillip]Chief Stewart PhillipPresident-- 30 --
For more information contact Chief Phillip at (250) 490-5314.

[admin]

Jan 09, 2003
By: Keith M. Landy

Hateful rant gives birth to new resolve.

David Ahenakew's anti-Semitic attack drew heartfelt outpouring of friendship and support from Aboriginal peoples across Canada.
The most enduring aspect of the David Ahenakew affair will not be his vile and vicious anti-Semitic attack but the heartfelt outpouring of friendship and support from aboriginal peoples and their leaders across Canada, and their powerful denunciation of Ahenakew's racist venom.

These members of Canada's First Nations may not have been aware that in 1990, the Canadian Jewish Congress wrote to the Indian Affairs minister of the day during the Oka crisis saying, "There can be no more important objective than the attainment through peaceful means of justice for Canada's aboriginal peoples."

They may not have known that CJC commended the establishment of the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples — but only if it "refrained from merely studying the issues, that is, recataloguing the problems Native peoples face. Rather, it must probe more deeply into the basic relationship between the First Nations and Canadian society and governments, and propose concrete, workable solutions to these long-standing problems."

Those who reached out to us last week likely had no idea that in 1998, CJC publicly condemned the residential schools as "a national shame in Canadian history."

What all of the people who contacted us — we were inundated with calls, e-mails, faxes — were acutely aware of, though, was that one of their leaders had shamed them through intolerance and bigotry.

They knew that the pain he had caused, though aimed at one group, had hit a much broader target, including their own community, and Canadian society at large. They understood the irony of a representative of one minority community that has experienced discrimination targeting another such community for a hateful diatribe.

They knew well before Ahenakew did, that, in the words of one chief, "silence was not an option." And so they spoke.

Yesterday, I met with Matthew Coon Come, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, and Perry Bellegarde, Chief of the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations, to discuss how best to move forward from this disturbing incident. Without hesitation, we renewed the commitment between the Jewish and aboriginal communities to walk the journey of peace and reconciliation together.

Together, we will build on the existing goodwill between Jewish and aboriginal Canadians and make the relationship stronger. We will share stories of ancient ties to ancestral lands. We will take stock of the ageless value in our traditions of heritage languages and culture and how we transmit them to successive generations. We will compare notes on our spiritual connections to our Creator.

And, yes, we will remind ourselves of our other common ground: Two communities that have experienced the full gamut of persecution, from racist jokes and stereotyping, through societal discrimination to attempted genocide.

We invite all Canadians to join us in the renewed dialogue. Clearly, a policy must be in place in our hearts and in our conduct that underscores zero tolerance for racism and hate speech. At the same time, we must all buy into the proposition that while political views — even those passionately held — can be freely expressed, such discourse must be conducted in ways compatible with basic Canadian values.

Canada's much-vaunted multiculturalism policy encourages communities to maintain and nurture their ethnocultural identities but with concomitant adherence to the overarching Canadian principles of civility, respect for diversity, social harmony and the rule of law. These are minimum obligations that accrue to citizenship and must be adhered to as the flipside of our Charter rights and freedoms.

George Bernard Shaw once wrote that, "The worst sin towards our fellow creatures is not to hate them, but to be indifferent toward them."

The Ahenakew affair began with hate but, thanks to the aboriginal peoples of this country, it will end with the complete opposite of indifference: Solidarity, support, mutual respect and enhanced friendship.

That will be its enduring legacy.

Keith M. Landy is president of the Canadian Jewish Congress.

[admin]

(Excerpted from the Criminal Code of Canada)

Hate Propaganda

Advocating genocide
318. (1) Every one who advocates or promotes genocide is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years.

Definition of "genocide"
(2) In this section, "genocide" means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy in whole or in part any identifiable group, namely,

(a) killing members of the group; or

(b) deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction.

Consent
(3) No proceeding for an offence under this section shall be instituted without the consent of the Attorney General.

Definition of "identifiable group"
(4) In this section, "identifiable group" means any section of the public distinguished by colour, race, religion or ethnic origin.

R.S., c. 11(1st Supp.), s. 1.

Public incitement of hatred
319. (1) Every one who, by communicating statements in any public place, incites hatred against any identifiable group where such incitement is likely to lead to a breach of the peace is guilty of

(a) an indictable offence and is liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years; or

(b) an offence punishable on summary conviction.

Wilful promotion of hatred
(2) Every one who, by communicating statements, other than in private conversation, wilfully promotes hatred against any identifiable group is guilty of

(a) an indictable offence and is liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years; or

(b) an offence punishable on summary conviction.
Defences
(3) No person shall be convicted of an offence under subsection (2)

(a) if he establishes that the statements communicated were true;

(b) if, in good faith, he expressed or attempted to establish by argument an opinion on a religious subject;

(c) if the statements were relevant to any subject of public interest, the discussion of which was for the public benefit, and if on reasonable grounds he believed them to be true; or

(d) if, in good faith, he intended to point out, for the purpose of removal, matters producing or tending to produce feelings of hatred toward an identifiable group in Canada.

Forfeiture
(4) Where a person is convicted of an offence under section 318 or subsection (1) or (2) of this section, anything by means of or in relation to which the offence was committed, on such conviction, may, in addition to any other punishment imposed, be ordered by the presiding provincial court judge or judge to be forfeited to Her Majesty in right of the province in which that person is convicted, for disposal as the Attorney General may direct.

Exemption from seizure of communication facilities
(5) Subsections 199(6) and (7) apply with such modifications as the circumstances require to section 318 or subsection (1) or (2) of this section.

Consent
(6) No proceeding for an offence under subsection (2) shall be instituted without the consent of the Attorney General.

Definitions
(7) In this section,

"communicating" «communiquer»
"communicating" includes communicating by telephone, broadcasting or other audible or visible means;

"identifiable group" «groupe identifiable»
"identifiable group" has the same meaning as in section 318;

"public place" «endroit public»
"public place" includes any place to which the public have access as of right or by invitation, express or implied;

"statements" «déclarations»
"statements" includes words spoken or written or recorded electronically or electro-magnetically or otherwise, and gestures, signs or other visible representations.

[Ahenakew fiasco]

Letter to the Editor of Turtle Island Native Network, in response to the Perspective - "Mr. Ahenakew, you were wrong, please apologize!"
http://www.turtleisland.org/discussion/ ... ?p=287#287
- - - - - - -

My reply for the whole Ahenakew fiasco!!

"He messed up badly - shame on you Mr Ahenakew!"

July 11, 2005

I agree with the article about Mr. Ahenakew that he should just apologize, and just shut up now!!!, he messed up badly and tried to blame it on his health condition, and now is trying to pull the rest of us First Nations in with his rationale, and keeps putting his foot in his mouth, as a First Nations he is embarrassing, and I am embarrassed for my Jewish friends who I made good connections with, in regards to the suffering of our nations, shame on you Mr Ahenakew!!

Jim Aleck
addictions@kfs.bc.ca

[Ahenakew's Appeal]

David Ahenakew's hate crime conviction for remarks about the Jews has been set aside by Saskatchewan court . . . New trial ordered!
June 2006
http://204.83.249.88/judgments/2006/QB2 ... kqb272.pdf
NOTE this is a link to a .pdf file

- - - - - - -

Aug 04, 2005 - CJC to seek intervener status in Ahenakew appeal

OTTAWA – Canadian Jewish Congress will seek intervener status in the legal appeal recently launched by former Aboriginal community leader David Ahenakew.

Ahenakew was found guilty in July of willfully promoting hatred against an identifiable group for comments he made to a reporter after a speech at a Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations conference, calling Jewish people a “disease” and saying Hitler was justified when he “fried six million of those guys.” Ahenakew is appealing on a number of grounds, including that his conversation with the reporter should have been considered private.

“We are confident that the conviction will be upheld, and we will work with the Crown in this case to ensure that David Ahenakew is held legally responsible for his actions,” said CJC National President Ed Morgan. “An appeal will give the courts a further chance to define and condemn hateful speech,” he added.

“The vast majority of Canada’s First Nations peoples do not share David Ahenakew’s views. CJC and the Canadian Jewish community continue to work with First Nations communities to fight injustice together,” Morgan noted.


-30-
Contact:
Wendy Lampert
National Communications Director
Canadian Jewish Congress
416-631-5844 (office)
wlampert@on.cjc.ca
www.cjc.ca

- - - - - - -

BACKGROUND
http://www.turtleisland.org/discussion/ ... .php?t=232

David Ahenakew is a Cree member of the Ahtahkakoop Indian Reserve in Saskatchewan. He served in the Canadian Armed forces for 16 years prior to entering First Nations politics. Mr. Ahenakew was leader of the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations for 10 years. He served as National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations from 1982 to 1985.

- - - - - - -

July 7, 2005

Assembly of First Nations 26th Annual General Assembly in Yellowknife

Canadian Jewish Congress President Ed Morgan spoke to the Chiefs in Assembly about the CJC’s interest in working together to address issues of mutual interest and concern, including combatting racism and discrimination in Canada.

- - - - - - -

Jul 08, 2005 - CJC welcomes guilty verdict in Ahenakew case

For immediate release

SASKATOON – Canadian Jewish Congress welcomed the guilty verdict rendered today in the case of David Ahenakew, a former Aboriginal leader.

Ahenakew was found guilty of willfully promoting hatred against an identifiable group for comments he made during an interview with a reporter following his speech at a Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations conference. In his conversation with the reporter, Ahenakew called Jewish people a "disease" and said Hitler was justified when he "fried six million of those guys."

"Crown Prosecutor Brent Krause and his team are to be commended for successfully making the case that Ahenakew's vile statements in a media interview amounted to the public, willful promotion of hatred," said June Avivi, Chair of CJC's Saskatchewan Region. "The anti-hate law is in place precisely to free the environment of hatred's most toxic manifestations, making a verdict of guilty the logical outcome," she noted.

"This verdict has given tangible expression to the views of Canadian society on crimes of hate; justice has been served," added CJC National President Ed Morgan. "The guilty verdict provides additional support to the decision by the Advisory Council of the Order of Canada to revoke Ahenakew's membership," he said. "His hateful remarks negate core Canadian values and are an affront to the Order's goal of rewarding those who contribute to the country's betterment."

"Ahenakew's actions may have temporarily captured the attention of Canadians, but they do not define the relationship between the Jewish and Aboriginal communities," Morgan noted. "Our communities have a long history of interconnection and compassion for each other's issues, and that will not change because of an individual."


-30-

Contact:
Wendy Lampert
National Director of Communications
Canadian Jewish Congress
416-631-5844 (office)
wlampert@on.cjc.ca
www.cjc.ca

- - - - - - -

Jul 06, 2005 - CJC welcomes Order of Canada decision to review David Ahenakew's membership

YELLOWKNIFE, N.W.T.- Canadian Jewish Congress welcomed the decision by the Order of Canada's Advisory Council to review the membership of former Aboriginal leader David Ahenakew.

The council has sent a letter to Ahenakew, providing him time to make submissions to the council on his own behalf before they make a final recommendation to the Governor General regarding his membership in the order.

Ahenakew has been charged with willfully promoting hatred against an identifiable group for comments he made during a speech at a Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations conference and to a reporter afterwards. In his conversation with the reporter, Ahenakew called Jewish people a "disease" and said Hitler was justified when he "fried six million of those guys." The verdict in the case will be announced Friday morning.

"This is an appropriate step," said CJC National President Ed Morgan, who is in Yellowknife, N.W.T. to speak at the Annual Meeting of the Assembly of First Nations. "Canadians are united in their abhorrence of hateful speech, and in that light, we welcome and support the Advisory Council's decision to act today," Morgan said.

"Regardless of what happens in the criminal proceedings, if the Advisory Council had not taken this step, Ahenakew's words would have brought the Order of Canada into disrepute," he added.

Morgan noted that Ahenakew's actions have not changed the positive relationship that exists between Aboriginal and Jewish Canadians. "Canada's aboriginal and Jewish communities share a deep commitment to moving ahead cooperatively and to working together to combat all forms of discrimination and to seek social justice," he said.

-30-
For more information contact:

Wendy Lampert
National Director of Communications
Canadian Jewish Congress
416-631-5844
wlampert@on.cjc.ca
www.cjc.ca

- - - - - - -

Jun 11, 2003 - AHENAKEW HATE CHARGE JUSTIFIED STATES

Ottawa - Canadian Jewish Congress indicated that it respects the office of the Saskatchewan Attorney General and accordingly supports the decision to charge David Ahenakew with a hate crime for comments he made on December 13, 2002, in the context of a Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations' (FSIN) meeting.

"The statements Mr. Ahenakew made could hardly have been more hateful. The charge laid today under the Criminal Code's anti-hate law, therefore, is justified," declared Keith Landy, CJC national president. "The law was introduced precisely to protect groups identified by such characteristics as race, religion and ethnic origin from publicly-expressed views that vilify and attack them and thereby undermine the promotion of justice, tolerance and respect for diversity in Canadian society."

"Still, there has been a big silver lining to the Ahenakew cloud," Mr. Landy added. "The response of distress and the expressions of solidarity by the leadership of aboriginal communities and their members have been overwhelming. The historic ties between our two peoples have in fact been strengthened and we are finding additional ways from one end of the country to the other to work together and support each other.”

"In any case," concluded Mr. Landy, " if there are mitigating circumstances these may help in sentencing but they cannot be used to avoid the laying of a charge. Mr. Ahenakew is accused of having broken the law. Of course he has every right to defend himself but if a guilty verdict results he must face the consequences of his actions."


-30-
Contact:

Manuel Prutschi
National Director of Community Relations Canadian Jewish Congress
(416) 631-5673
or
Bruce Kurta
Director of Communications, Canadian Jewish Congress Ontario Region
(416) 575-4675 (cell)

- - - - - - -

Jan 08, 2003 - Jewish and First Nations’ leaders meet

TORONTO – Keith Landy, Canadian Jewish Congress National President met in Toronto today with Matthew Coon Come, Assembly of First Nations (AFN) National Chief and Perry Bellegarde, Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations’ chief and AFN Vice Chief. The leaders arranged the meeting shortly after former Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations senator David Ahenakew made his antisemitic comments. Ed Morgan, CJC Ontario Region Chair and Ellen Cole, CJC National Chair of Community Relations were also in attendance.

Mr. Landy comments, “I thanked National Chief Coon Come and Chief Bellegarde for their unequivocal denunciations of the hateful remarks. Their outreach to our community has done much to alleviate the pain and shock Mr. Ahenakew caused.

“It was a powerful and poignant gesture when National Chief Coon Come joined CJC leaders in Montreal to pray alongside our people in synagogue at the Sabbath services. His leadership and integrity have been exemplary throughout this matter. “I think it is indicative of the strong bonds our two communities have built over the years that our relationship has not been damaged. Indeed they have been strengthened,” Mr. Landy continued.

National Chief Coon Come said, “First Nations and the Jewish community have stood together on many occasions in the past and we must continue to build on and enhance our mutual dialogue. We want to reach out to our Jewish brothers and sisters and extend our hand in friendship and renew our historic ties. Both our peoples share, at the core of our moral and ethical systems, a fundamental respect for all peoples. We want to explore the many ways we can work together and support each other.”

The leaders discussed issues of mutual concern to their communities and the need to continue combating discrimination as manifested by anti-aboriginal racism and antisemitism. Ideas for sharing agendas and the importance for Jewish and First Nations’ peoples to increase the knowledge and awareness of each other’s history and current circumstances were key items discussed.

Also attending were Manuel Prutschi, CJC National Director of Community Relations and Don Kelly, AFN Director of Communications.

-30-


Contact:
Ron Singer
Director of Communications
Canadian Jewish Congress
613-233-8703 ext 233

Don Kelly
Director of Communications
Assembly of First Nations
613 241-6789 ext. 320

- - - - - -

Dec 17, 2002 - CJC COMMENTS ON AHENAKEW APOLOGY

For immediate release OTTAWA – Reacting to the apology of David Ahenakew, Canadian Jewish Congress acknowledges his admission of the hurt he has caused to the Jewish community, his own people and to all Canadians.

“This is a positive gesture,” remarks Keith Landy CJC national president, “but Mr. Ahenakew himself said that words are not enough and it will require actions to make amends. In our view it will require extraordinary actions.”

“What is more important to us are the apologies and warm words of support and solidarity we have received from current First Nation leaders across the country. The personal outreach that we have been receiving over the past two days has been very reassuring. In my conversations with native leaders, we have resolved not to let these horrendous comments sour the good relations we have with the First Nations,” continues Mr. Landy.

“Assembly of First Nations National chief Matthew Coon Come telephoned me prior to his news conference yesterday to convey his apology and to let me know how disturbed he was by these comments that he described as antisemitic and hateful,” says the CJC leader. “His strong statements issued in the AFN news release indicate a renewed commitment for our communities to continue to work together.”

Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations chief Perry Bellegarde also telephoned the CJC office early yesterday to express his outrage. Faxes e-mails and phone calls are still pouring in from many First Nation chiefs as it has to the Jewish community in Saskatchewan.

CJC has written to Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin, in her capacity as Chair of the Advisory Council of the Order of Canada, requesting that the award of Member of the Order of Canada bestowed upon Chief David Ahenakew be revoked.

In the letter, Keith Landy writes “. . .someone capable of uttering such despicable remarks sullies the honour of the Order of Canada and is unfit to wear its badge, emblematic of the best of Canadian values and shared principles.”

-30-

Contact:
Ron Singer
Director of Communications
613 233-8703 ext 223
rons@cjc.ca

- - - - - - -

Dec 15, 2002 - CJC shocked by Ahenakew’s racist comments

OTTAWA – Canadian Jewish Congress is appalled by the racist comments of David Ahenakew, senator and former leader of the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations (FISN) and the Assembly of First Nations (AFN). Hateful attacks primarily against the Jewish people as well as members of the South Asian community and others were made during a speech to an FISN conference. The shocking extent of his antisemitism was further revealed in a follow-up interview.

“These vicious and vile remarks stagger the mind and sicken the heart,” states Keith Landy, CJC national president. “Mr. Ahenakew has disgraced himself, his community and the Canadian Armed Forces in which he served. From here on in he ought to be relegated to the obscurity he so richly deserves.”

“We acknowledge that chief Bellegarde dissociated the FISN from the remarks and are encouraged by his declared intention to meet with Saskatchewan's Jewish community,” continues Mr. Landy. “We hope that what would emerge out of such a meeting is the validation of a zero tolerance policy towards any racist expression and a rejection of those who engage in it.”

Mr. Landy says he will contact Assembly of First Nations national chief Matthew Coon Come. “CJC and the AFN have been linked by a shared commitment to pursue justice and combat discrimination. I hope to speak with National Chief Coon Come soon so we can not only reaffirm, but indeed strengthen the very good relationship enjoyed by our two communities,” concludes the CJC leader.

-30-


Contact:
Ron Singer
Director of Communications
613 233-8703 ext 223

[Aboriginals go to Israel]

Mission to Israel stirs interest among First Nations

September 7, 2005
Canadian Jewish News

By PAUL LUNGEN
Staff Reporter

A forest fire has spread across Manitoba reaching south to Oklahoma and even as far away as Brazil.

Although no trees were actually destroyed in the conflagration, Rev. Pastor Raymond McLean believes the vivid imagery is the best way to describe the widespread interest in a recently completed aboriginal mission to Israel.

News of this year’s visit to Israel is spreading fast in native communities – like a “domino effect, or a chain reaction” – Rev. McLean said. People in Thompson, in Manitoba’s far north, have inquired about it and expressed interest in joining next year’s trip, the fourth he will participate in. People in New Brunswick, Alberta, Saskatchewan and even a caller from Oklahoma have all heard about the Holy Land visit and want to sign on, he said.

And why not? This year’s trip, which attracted 44 participants, offered everything from spiritual sustenance to political discourse on topics near and dear to the hearts of Canadian native leaders, he said.

Speaking by telephone from Winnipeg, Rev. McLean, pastor at the First Nations Family Worship Centre, said, “There’s no place like Israel. When I went the first time, I was so overtaken by everything, the land and the people.”

People back home quickly become enthusiastic when he describes the trip and they yearn to visit “the Holy Land of the Bible.”

On the most recent trip, which spanned eight days in mid-August, several native leaders joined evangelical ministers, educators and others on the trip. Grand Chief Dr. Sydney Garrioch of the Manitoba Keewatnook Ininew Okimowin, Grand Chief Arnold Ouskan, Keewatin Tribal Council, and Chief David Harper of the Garden Hill First Nation, were among the dignitaries. Altogether, Manitoba tribal elders representing the Saulteaux, Ojibway, Cree, Oji-Cree and Sioux people took part in the trip. They were joined by Alan Yusim, midwest regional director of B’nai Brith Canada, who served as facilitator.

Participants in the solidarity mission were moved by their visits to the Western Wall, the remains of the Antonia Fortress, where Jesus was whipped, and the Way of the Cross, Rev. McLean said.

They were feted by the mayors of Haifa and Jerusalem and they visited the Knesset where they were greeted by an Israeli parliamentarian with responsibility for visiting Christian groups.

Mission participants also took the opportunity to discuss issues of interest to both Israelis and natives, including housing and cultural retention.

“We can identify with the Jewish people as going through the same phase in history,” Rev. McLean said.

Both peoples suffered oppression and murder and both have been painted as “the bad guys.”

Native leaders admired the ability of the Jews to maintain their culture.

“We were so amazed that Israelis were able to revive their native tongue, the same language that was spoken 3,000 years ago.” Canadian natives can learn from that, as young aboriginals often have little connection to their language heritage, he added.

“The main attraction” of Israel, he continued, “is that it’s a country that came from nothing. It was desolate.”

Yusim said the first visit to Israel by Manitoba natives was sponsored by B’nai Brith Canada in the aftermath of the David Ahenakew incident. In December 2002, Ahenakew, a former native leader, made remarks about Jews that eventually led to his conviction for promoting hatred. The 2003 trip was followed by anti-hate programming designed to bring Jewish and native peoples closer together, he said.

In 2004 and 2005, McLean led his own groups to Israel. The recently concluded trip was billed as the “Stand with Israel” mission and consisted of a coalition of the New Allied Christian Caucus for Israel and the League of First Nations Leaders, Yusim noted.

“It is important to stress that these First Nations leaders and members of the Christian caucus came to Israel on their own accord and took a vocal stand with Israel and expressed clearly their opposition to anti-Semitism, both in their own communities and around the world,” he said.

Rev. McLean said Ahenakew’s outbursts don’t represent the views of native peoples, adding he’d like to put the Ahenakew incident “behind us. I want good to overshadow that.”

After the group’s return to Canada, news of the visit spread quickly. The Oklahoma pastor told him there was nothing like it in his area and suggested Manitoba natives were serving as “a role model for them,” Rev. McLean said.

A Canadian evangelist in South America, who is Rev. McLean’s friend, even suggested he’d spread word of the trip to congregations in Brazil.

Rev. McLean is optimistic the trip will be back bigger than ever next year.

“We might have to book a jumbo plane,” he quipped.

- - - - - - -

Aboriginal Mission to Israel aims to repudiate antisemitism of Ahenakew - Follow-up tour with Chief Fontaine to take place

Posted On 08/05/05

Aboriginal Mission to Israel aims to repudiate antisemitism of Ahenakew - Follow-up tour with Chief Fontaine to take place

Toronto, August 5, 2005 –B’nai Brith will be accompanying a First Nations “Stand with Israel” Mission Tour that departs from Winnipeg for Israel on August 13, 2005. The “New Allied Christian Caucus for Israel” group, consisting of First Nations leaders from across Manitoba, will be led by Southeast Aboriginal Ministries Pastor Rev. Raymond McLean.

“This mission - the third consecutive one - was inspired by the initial
2003 ‘Holocaust and Hope Educator’s Tour’ sponsored by B’nai Brith Canada’s League for Human Rights,” said Reverend McLean. “The first B’nai Brith-Aboriginal Mission, which followed directly the outbreak of the David Ahenakew affair, was designed to build bridges between members of the Jewish community and the Assembly of First Nations. As we get set to depart this time around, we realize that much work still needs to be done. An important part of our mandate aims to destroy the seeds of antisemitism sown by two of our First Nation leaders.”

Frank Dimant, Executive Vice-President of B’nai Brith Canada, stated: “We will continue to work toward greater understanding between our Jewish community and the First Nations peoples. We were the first to call for a criminal investigation of Ahenakew and we applaud the recent hate crimes conviction. We are seeking intervener status in his appeal and are confident that his conviction will be upheld. Just as we successfully led a national campaign to have Ahenakew’s Order of Canada removed, we are equally certain that his is an isolated voice - his hate-filled messages neither reflected in the Aboriginal leaders who are traveling with us to Israel, nor in the wider Aboriginal community.

“B’nai Brith officials will shortly be leading their own Mission to Israel with the Assembly of First Nations Chief Phil Fontaine, with whom we look forward to continuing the productive dialogue that we have begun. I congratulate the group of Aboriginal leaders that will soon depart for Israel on their educational tour, who have gone out of their way to distance themselves from Ahenakew’s remarks.”

-30-
For further information contact, Karen Lazar, Director of Communications:
416-633-6224 X 140 (office) / 647-999-9835 (cell)

B’nai Brith has been active in Canada since 1875 as the Jewish community’s foremost human rights organization.

- - - - - - -

Posted On 07/08/05
Reacting to David Ahenakew’s press conference following his criminal conviction, B’nai Brith Canada issued the following statement:

“David Ahenakew has proved yet again that his hate crime conviction is fully justified. Far from showing any remorse, he insists that his past statements, such as Jews are a ‘disease’, constitute free speech”, said Frank Dimant, Executive Vice President of B’nai Brith Canada.

“What is particularly outrageous is that Ahenakew hides behind the good name of First Nations peoples by invoking their communal history to justify his willful promotion of hatred. His allegations of conspiracy theories targeting the Jewish community should be denounced, especially given that similar statements have just recently been criticized by the Supreme Court of Canada in the Mugasera case.

“Should he seek an appeal, B’nai Brith Canada will immediately ask for intervener status.”

-30-


For further information contact: Anita Bromberg at (416) 802 2813

- - - - - - -

Posted On 07/08/05
B’nai Brith welcomes Ahenakew’s hate crime conviction

Toronto, July 8, 2005 – B’nai Brith welcomes the conviction of David Ahenakew on the criminal charge of willfully promoting hatred against an identifiable group contrary to section 319(2) of the Criminal Code.

Frank Dimant, Executive Vice-President of B’nai Brith Canada, stated: “We commend the Crown for moving ahead with the case as B’nai Brith Canada had requested, and for establishing through a strong and effective prosecution that Ahenakew’s hate-filled statements are indeed a hate crime. We hope that this conviction will serve as a deterrent to other hate mongers in our midst.”

-30-


For further information contact Anita Bromberg, Legal Counsel, at (416) 802 2813 or Alan Yusim at (204) 299 7001 (cell)

- - - - - - -

Posted On 07/07/05
With Ahenakew's Order of Canada finally in the balance, B'nai Brith has team standing by to monitor Saskatoon hearing tomorrow

B'nai Brith Canada has termed as “positive” the revelation that the Governor General has begun the process of revoking the Order of Canada of former First Nations chief David Ahenakew, charged with willfully promoting hatred against an identifiable group, if he does not first resign. This development, coming on the eve of tomorrow’s criminal hearing in Saskatoon, is a step closer to bringing long overdue closure to “a disappointing period of prevarication in the history of the Order of Canada”.

"In order to make a clear distinction between Ahenakew’s hate-filled sentiments and the many worthy Order members across the country, we look for a formal announcement by Rideau Hall that Ahenakew’s Order has actually been revoked”, said Frank Dimant, Executive Vice-President of B'nai Brith Canada. "Canadians from across the nation have made it abundantly clear that Ahenkew does not represent this country's highest ideals. The hundreds of people who responded to B'nai Brith's campaign calling on the Governor General to take action, have spoken loud and clear, and now at last it appears that their voices have been heard. We have always held that the outcome of his trial should have no bearing on the issue of revoking his Order. He has brought disrepute to the Order which is, in itself, grounds for revocation, irrespective of what the criminal justice system will rule tomorrow.”

-30-


For further information from B’nai Brith’s legal and human rights experts contact:
Alan Yusim, Midwest Regional Director, who will attend the hearing in Saskatoon, at (204) 299 7001 (cell)
Anita Bromberg, Legal Counsel, at (416) 802 2813

- - - - - - -

Posted On 06/09/05
B’nai Brith urges Order of Canada inductees to push for action on Ahenakew

Toronto, June 9, 2005 – With just weeks to go before the resumption of the hate-crime trial of Order of Canada recipient David Ahenakew, B’nai Brith Canada is calling on the 43 recipients being invested into the Order tomorrow to protest the failure to remove Ahenakew from their ranks.

“It is clear that Ahenakew has unashamedly dishonoured the Order and its truly deserving recipients. No criminal test of law will change what Canadians already know in their hearts to be true,” said Frank Dimant, B’nai Brith Canada’s Executive Vice-President. “Racism is racism and it ought not to be countenanced by the nation’s most distinguished body, whose very motto speaks of ‘Desiderantes meliorem patriam’ – those desiring a better country.

“B’nai Brith’s nation-wide campaign urging the Governor General to revoke Ahenakew’s Order has been gaining in momentum. Prominent members of the Order have lent their voices to demand what must be a higher standard of excellence for Order recipients. Just recently, Toronto member, Bill Marshall, CM, announced publicly that he had placed a strip of black tape over the centre of his pin as a sign of mourning, to be worn until Ahenakew’s Order is removed.

“B’nai Brith encourages the newest Order inductees and existing members to follow Bill Marshall’s example, by using the occasion of tomorrow’s investiture ceremony to mark their own pins in a similar fashion. If people who express such vile views are allowed to hold Canada’s highest honour, it will make a mockery of our country and its values.”

-30-

For further information contact, Karen Lazar, Director of Communications:
416-633-6224 X 140 (office) / 647-999-9835 (cell)

- - - - - - -

Posted On 04/18/05
Chief Nelson’s apology is no excuse for ignorance, says B’nai Brith Canada

Winnipeg, April 18, 2005 – Roseau River Reserve Chief Terrance Nelson today held a press conference that ostensibly was to be an apology to the Jewish community for the poisonous letter he penned last week, charging that the Jewish-controlled media was inciting hatred against the Aboriginal peoples.

“Chief Nelson’s feeble attempt at an apology just doesn’t cut it,” said David Matas, Senior Legal Counsel to B’nai Brith Canada. “An apology isn’t sufficient if it is accompanied by ignorance and repetition. There was no real understanding for the hurt that he had caused. Instead we found the Aboriginal leader standing his ground, and reiterating some of the age-old antisemitic canards that he had uttered in the first place.

“In his statement today, Nelson professes to have no true understanding of what antisemitism is. In answer to his query, we say the following: Antisemitism is the act of vilifying an identifiably ethnic group - namely the Jewish people - for no other reason other than their being Jewish. When former First Nations Chief David Ahenakew justifies the genocide of six million of our people, that is antisemitism. When remarks are made that suggest a so-called Jewish media monopoly aimed at spreading hate, that is antisemitism. And it must be condemned, along with all hate-filled messaging targeting any group of peoples.

“Today was a failed opportunity to embark upon a journey of dialogue and understanding. We repeat our earlier call urging that Chief Nelson immediately be removed from his position of leadership. The First Nations community must repudiate strongly Nelson’s remarks and not close its ranks around him.”

-30-

For further information contact, Karen Lazar, Director of Communications:
416-633-6224 X 140 (office) / 647-999-9835 (cell)

- - - - - - -

Posted On 04/11/05
“The scapegoating of Jews by Manitoba Aboriginal leader
cannot be allowed to stand,” says B’nai Brith Canada

Toronto, April 11, 2005 – Following the hearings into hate-crime charges against David Ahenakew, Roseau River Reserve Chief Terrance Nelson has penned a poisonous letter predicting a dramatic rise in hatred and violence toward Jews. In the letter, Chief Nelson reiterated the age-old antisemitic canard that Jews control the media, and use it to teach hatred against the First Nations people in Canada.

“The scapegoating of Jews by a First Nations chief in Manitoba cannot be allowed to stand,” said Steven Slimovitch, National Legal Counsel to B’nai Brith Canada, who had monitored the Ahenakew hate-crime trial. “Chief Nelson must immediately be removed from his position of leadership.

“It is hoped that Nelson’s remarks are indicative of a fringe position, and that they do not reflect the mainstream of Aboriginal society. Haven’t we learned anything from the Ahenakew affair? Nelson’s remarks must be met with unequivocal and immediate condemnation by the leaders of the Aboriginal community, whose voices must be loud enough to drown out the words of hate.

“Following Ahenakew’s initial diatribe in December 2002, B’nai Brith undertook to sponsor a mission to Israel for educators from various Aboriginal communities in an attempt to build bridges between members of the Jewish community and the Assembly of First Nations. It is this important educational work that must continue in order to build the necessary foundation for stopping hate in its tracks.”

-30-

For further information contact, Karen Lazar, Director of Communications:
416-633-6224 X 140 (office) / 647-999-9835 (cell)

- - - - - - -

Posted On 04/08/05
Ahenakew should be stripped of his Order of Canada and a guilty verdict rendered

Toronto, April 8, 2005 – B’nai Brith Canada, which has been monitoring the hate crime trial of David Ahenakew, is urging that the former leader of the Federation of Saskatchewan Indians (FSIN) be held to account for his poisonous words.

“The court should find Ahenakew guilty, and impose an appropriately severe sentence to reflect his insidious messaging. Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms is intended to offer protection to minorities, not to provide justification for attacking them,” said Steven Slimovitch, National Legal Counsel to B’nai Brith Canada.

“Ahenakew made it clear from his own testimony at the trial that he stands by his hate-filled remarks. His distorted ramblings on Jews, the Holocaust and the Second World War demonstrated lack of contrition on his part.”

Frank Dimant, Executive Vice-President of B’nai Brith Canada, added: “There is no reason for the Government to delay any longer its decision on removal of Ahenakew’s Order of Canada. His performance at the trial provides even more evidence of a deep-seated bigotry. If people who express such vile views are allowed to hold this country’s highest honour, it will make a mockery of our country and its multicultural traditions, and tarnish by association the truly worthy members of the Order. A man like Ahenakew should not be amongst their ranks.”

-30-

For more information, please contact Karen Lazar, Director of Communications:
416-633-6224 X 140 (office) / 647-999-9835 (cell)

- - - - - - -

Aboriginal Educators, B’nai Brith Canada Officials Gather in Toronto in Preparation for Holocaust and Hope Trip to Israel
Posted On 07/28/03
Toronto — A group of Aboriginal educators gathered at the offices of B’nai Brith Canada today in preparation for their participation in an upcoming Holocaust and Hope education program in Israel organized by the League for Human Rights of B’nai Brith Canada.

The League for Human Rights is a national volunteer agency dedicated to combating racial discrimination and antisemitism, bigotry and hate, and to promoting human rights for all Canadians. The Holocaust and Hope program, created almost 20 years ago, offers educators an opportunity to learn about the Holocaust through a multi-faceted program of lectures, on-site visits and personal contacts with survivors.

“This is a very significant event,” said Toni Silberman, Chair of the League for Human Rights, Ontario Region of B’nai Brith Canada. “It is a tangible demonstration of the sincere desire among Aboriginal and Jewish Canadians to reach out and learn about one another. We have a shared legacy that impels us to bear witness, and we hope that all of the participants will be inspired with a sense of our individual and collective strengths and possibilities as a society.”

“The idea to create a Holocaust and Hope tour specifically tailored to our friends in the Aboriginal community came during a meeting we had last January with First Nations leaders following the Ahenakew affair,” added Rochelle President of B’nai Brith Canada. “It’s great that we’ve been able to ensure that something positive comes out of that sorry episode and we are determined not to let the momentum of this program dissipate.”

Participants depart for Israel July 28 and return to Canada August 7.

The creation of an Aboriginal Holocaust and Hope program was one of several initiatives agreed to between B’nai Brith Canada and First Nations leaders aimed at promoting understanding and cooperation between Jewish and Aboriginal Canadians. Others include a visit by First Nations leaders to Israel and a fact-finding tour by Canadian Jewish leaders to First Nations communities throughout Canada.

- - - - - - -

B’NAI BRITH CANADA CONGRATULATES NEW AFN NATIONAL CHIEF
Posted On 07/17/03
Ottawa, July 17, 2003 … B’nai Brith Canada today extended its congratulations to Phil Fontaine upon his election as National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations.

“We are happy that we have already had the opportunity to meet with Mr. Fontaine to discuss avenues of mutual interest for the future,” observed Rochelle Wilner, President of B’nai Brith Canada. “He is a talented and astute individual who will serve First Nations Canadians very well. With the election over, the time has come for the leaders of our two communities to roll up their sleeves and work together to increase mutual understanding.”

Frank Dimant, Executive Vice President, stated: “On July 28th, a group of Aboriginal educators will be leaving for Israel on our League for Human Rights Holocaust and Hope Educators Tour. This is one of several initiatives agreed to by B’nai Brith and the former AFN administration in the aftermath of the Ahenakew affair. We are now ready to move forward with the second stage of our planning with visits by B’nai Brith leadership to various First Nations communities in Canada.”

-30-

- - - - - - -

[First Nations Embassy]

First Nations pastor plans Jerusalem ‘embassy’
November 24, 2005
Canadian Jewish News

By MYRON LOVE
Prairies Correspondent

WINNIPEG — In the wake of a recent visit by B’nai Brith Canada and Israeli representatives to two First Nations communities in remote northern Manitoba, Winnipeg pastor Rev. Raymond McLean is making plans to move to Jerusalem and open a “First Nations Embassy” with himself as the first ambassador.

The Ahenakew affair was the catalyst for closer relations of late between Jews and native people, said Alan Yusim, director of B’nai Brith’s Winnipeg office.

After First Nations leader David Ahenakew praised Hitler to a reporter in 2002, saying the Nazi dictator “fried” six million Jews to prevent Jews from taking over the world, B’nai Brith contacted Manitoba First Nations leaders and educators and arranged for a First Nations mission to Israel.

There were 10 participants, including Rev. McLean, on the first “Holocaust and Hope Mission” in 2003. The group learned about the history of Israel and the Jewish People, and about the Holocaust. They were also exposed to Israeli culture.

Rev McLean himself organized the second mission – with B’nai Brith’s assistance – in the summer of 2004. Close to 30 First Nations educators and community members paid their own way. This past summer, McLean and Yusim led 44 native leaders on a third such tour of Israel.

“We met with Israeli government officials from the Foreign Ministry and NGO representatives and discussed how Israel might be able to assist impoverished Canadian First Nations communities to develop infrastructure using Israeli expertise,” Yusim said.

“We have since had meetings with the Assembly of First Nations Chiefs to discuss some initiatives.”

On Nov. 10, B’nai Brith and Israeli representative paid a return visit to two First Nations communities in Manitoba.

Yusim, B’nai Brith executive vice-president Frank Dimant and B’nai Brith legal council Anita Bromberg, accompanied by Ronan Gil-Or, deputy head of Mission at the Israeli embassy in Ottawa; Vivian Silver, executive director of the Negev Institute for Strategic Peace and Development (and a former Winnipegger); and Rabbi Alan Green of Winnipeg’s Shaarey Zedek Synagogue visited the isolated communities of Tadoule Lake and Oxford House.

Dimant was declared an honorary chief at Oxford House, and the local people and visitors exchanged speeches and prayers, as well as dream catchers and Shabbat candles.

“We stressed the many historical and cultural similarities between us,” Yusim said.

“Both peoples have suffered persecution. We’ve lost our land. We have had to struggle to preserve our language and culture in the face of great adversity. And we have both been victims of genocide.”

The natives and Jews discussed possible joint ventures in eco-tourism, geothermal energy development and hothouse agricultural initiatives.

As for Rev McLean’s setting up residence in Jerusalem, he said he has not set a date yet, but will be moving in the next few months.

“Most likely, I will be focusing on education and advocacy activities,” he said. “I would like to encourage more of our people to visit Israel.”

- - - - - - -

Native Peoples Travel to Israel
120 Drums Ministry Team
21 year old Rachel Mosley (Pauite/Shoshone/Assiniboine)
http://www.nativeyouthmagazine.com/prof ... 8&pfid=130

[First Nations and Israel]

CJC, AFN travel to Israel for educational mission

TORONTO, Feb. 17, 2006

In the largest-ever mission to Israel by a North American First Nation group, First Nation leaders from across Canada will learn how their Israeli counterparts preserve their historic languages and culture as part of the first joint Canadian Jewish Congress-Assembly of First Nations (AFN) visit to Israel.

During this six-day educational journey co-chaired by CJC National
President Ed Morgan and AFN National Chief Phil Fontaine, First Nation Chiefs, women and experts in the fields of business, law and academics will learn about best practices in agriculture, aquaculture and the preservation of minority languages from Israeli experts.

"Indigenous people in Canada have much in common with the people of
Israel, including a respect of the land and their languages. This mission is
an excellent opportunity for us to share our values and our traditional ways
of life, in the hope of building greater understanding, awareness and respect for our similarities and differences, both at home and abroad," said Fontaine.

"We share values and similar historical experiences with our First
Nations friends," said Morgan. "This trip presents an exceptional challenge
and opportunity to learn about what each of our communities holds most dear - our culture and our history."

While in Israel, the group will visit numerous sites of cultural,
religious and historical significance, including the Yad Vashem Holocaust
memorial in Jerusalem. They will meet with Canada's ambassador to Israel, Donald Sinclair, and will have the opportunity to explore kibbutz, or
collective farm, life.

The mission arrived in Israel this morning and returns Wednesday, February 22. CJC CEO Bernie M. Farber will provide professional support for the trip.

The Assembly of First Nations is the national organization representing
First Nations citizens in Canada.

Canadian Jewish Congress represents the Jewish communities of Canada.

Backgrounder:
Participants on CJC-AFN Mission to Israel


MISSION CHAIRS:

Phil Fontaine
National Chief, Assembly of First Nations
Member, Sakgeeng Ojibway Nation, Manitoba

Ed Morgan
National President, Canadian Jewish Congress


MISSION PARTICIPANTS - FIRST NATIONS LEADERS:

Second Peter Barlow
Chief, Indian Island Nation, New Brunswick

Kelly Bird
Chief, Mosquito Grizzley Bear's Head First Nation, Saskatchewan

Beverley Jacobs
President, Native Women's Association of Canada
Member, Six Nations of the Grand River, Ontario

Tina Levesque
Chief, Brokenhead Ojibway Nation, Manitoba

Rick O'Brien
AFN Regional Chief, Yukon Territory


MISSION PARTICIPANTS - INVITED GUESTS:

Bernie M. Farber
Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Jewish Congress

Blaine Favel
Advisor to AFN National Chief, Calgary

Brenda Gedeon-Miller
Executive Director, Migmawe Mawiomi Secretariat (Tribal Council)
Member, Listiguj, Quebec

Fred Kelly
Elder,
Member, Onigaming First Nation, Ontario
Accompanied by his wife, Sharlene Kelly

Jack London
AFN Legal Counsel and CJC volunteer
Accompanied by his wife, Belva London

Kathleen Mahoney
AFN Advisor on Indian Residential Schools and University of Calgary Law
and Human Rights Professor, Alberta

Kathleen McHugh
Co-Chair, AFN Women's Council
Member, Siksika Nation, Alberta

Frank Meawasige
First Nation Artist and Entrepreneur,
Member, Serpent River First Nation, Ontario

Anna Morgan
Freelance journalist, Toronto; wife of CJC National President Ed Morgan

David Porter
Chair, Kaska Dena Council, Vice-Chair of the Council for Yukon Indians
Member, Kaska Nation, British Columbia

Dr. Cora Voyageur
Professor of Sociology, University of Calgary, Alberta, with academic
interests in culture, identity, women's issues and Aboriginal issues

Donna Wuttunee
Regional Director, Industry Canada, Aboriginal Business Canada for
Western Canada and the North
Member, Red Pheasant First Nation, Saskatchewan

For further information: Bernie M. Farber, CJC CEO, 011-972-50-406-1266
(Israel cell phone), bfarber@on.cjc.ca
Wendy Lampert, CJC National Director of Communications, (416) 631-5844 (office) or (416) 845-4674 (cell), wlampert@on.cjc.ca
Ian McLeod, AFN Bilingual Communications Officer, (613) 241-6789 ext. 336 or cell (613) 859-4335; Nancy Pine, Communications
Advisor, Office of the National Chief, (613) 241-6789 ext. 243 or cell
(613) 298-6382

[David Ahenakew -New Trial]

Former leader must face a new trial for promoting hatred . . .

News and Comment
by Tehaliwaskenhas
Bob Kennedy, ( Onyota'a:ka / Oneida)
Copyright
Turtle Island Native Network
http://www.turtleisland.org

January 14, 2008

The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial for David Ahenakew for wilfully promoting hatred in "shocking, brutal and hurtful" comments he made five years ago.

"The trial judge did not take into account all of the evidence bearing on the question of whether Mr. Ahenakew "wilfully promoted" hatred. As a result, the appeal judge made no error in ordering a new trial," stated the Court of Appeal as it dismissed the Crown's appeal from a decision of the Court of Queen's Bench which had quashed the conviction.

Mr. Ahenakew, a former AFN National Chief, made comments when interviewed by a Saskatchewan newspaper reporter in 2002. He was convicted following a trial in Provincial Court. Then the Court of Queen's Bench said the trial judge, in reaching his decision, had not considered all of the evidence relevant to the question of whether Mr. Ahenakew had the intention necessary for a finding of guilt.

The Court of Appeal agreed with the Court of Queen's Bench. It said Mr. Ahenakew's comments, on any standard, were shocking, brutal and hurtful but noted that this was not the measure of the provisions of the Criminal Code that prescribe the offence of wilfully promoting hatred. Now - a new trial has been ordered.

This all began in 2002 when David Ahenakew spoke at a conference. In the course of his remarks, he made a disparaging comment about people of the Jewish faith.

After the speech, he was asked for an interview by a newspaper reporter. The interview was brief and confrontational.

Mr. Ahenakew made statements to the reporter which were, in effect, a rationalization of the Holocaust.

Mr. Ahenakew was charged under s. 319(2) of the Criminal Code with wilfully promoting hatred.

Saskatchewan Court of Appeal
The DECISION
http://www.lawsociety.sk.ca/judgments/2 ... k34eut.pdf